Are We Finally Being Heard? The Bus KSI Network and the Future of National Bus Safety
For years, bus drivers, trade unionists and safety campaigners have called for better safety data, independent investigation, confidential reporting, learning from serious incidents and recognition that working conditions affect public safety.
I have now discovered that a national, Department for Transport-funded network is pursuing remarkably similar objectives.
The question I find myself asking is:
Are we finally beginning to be heard?
I recently came across something I had previously heard very little about: the Bus Knowledge Sharing and Incident Network — the Bus KSI Network.
The more I have looked into it, the more interested I have become.
Not because I agree automatically with everything it does.
Not because it already has all the answers.
And certainly not because it has yet become the independent national investigation body I and others have campaigned for.
But because its stated objectives overlap remarkably closely with issues that bus workers, safety campaigners and trade unions have been raising for years.
That deserves attention.
It also deserves engagement.
What is the Bus KSI Network?
The Bus KSI Network sits within the Bus Centre of Excellence, which is funded by the Department for Transport and run by the Chartered Institution of Highways and Transportation.
The Bus Centre of Excellence was established to support bus reform, improve capability across the sector, share best practice and connect people involved in delivering bus services and infrastructure.
Its membership is free and is open to people working in and around the bus sector.
The Bus KSI Network itself was established in 2023.
Its purpose is described as improving bus safety nationally by bringing together safety experts and bus professionals from across the industry to share learning, develop best practice and influence the policy and regulatory direction of bus safety.
That already makes it significant.
But its longer-term ambition is even more interesting.
The Network's own published material states that its long-term vision is to develop towards an RAIB-style board — referring to the Rail Accident Investigation Branch model — with bus safety forming part of a wider government-led road-safety investigation structure.
That stopped me in my tracks.
Because that is very close to something I and others have been campaigning for nationally.
What does the Network actually want to do?
Its published objectives include facilitating learning from fatal and serious bus incidents, sharing investigation findings and recommendations, identifying themes and trends, giving people access to subject specialists, developing best practice and making the case for continued open safety knowledge-sharing with government support.
The Network has already looked at subjects including bus fires, bridge strikes, driver fatigue, risk management and wider safety behaviour.
A particularly good example involved TfL identifying a higher rate of fire incidents involving a particular bus type.
Similar incidents were then identified outside London.
The technical learning was capable of being applied more widely, so information was shared with other operators nationally.
That is exactly what a safety-learning system should do.
An incident in one operator or city should not remain knowledge trapped inside that organisation if the same risk could exist elsewhere.
It is also looking beyond blaming the individual
This is perhaps the part that interests me most.
The work associated with the Network increasingly encompasses vehicle design, driver fatigue, ergonomics, behavioural science, passenger safety and technology.
The launch of TfL's Bus Safety Standard 2 through the KSI Network included Advanced Emergency Braking, Intelligent Speed Assistance, safer vehicle-front design, improved interiors and future work on inclusive driver cab design, fatigue and distraction prevention, behavioural passenger safety and bridge-strike prevention.
That is systems thinking.
A Safe System does not simply say:
“The driver must not make a mistake.”
It asks:
“How do we design the vehicle, road, timetable, workplace, technology and management system so that one mistake does not automatically become a tragedy?”
That distinction matters enormously.
I have been asking similar questions for years
This is where discovering the KSI Network became particularly interesting for me personally.
My involvement in bus-safety campaigning did not start with this Network.
It developed through years of listening to drivers, working through my trade union and learning from people who had already been challenging the system.
One of those people was Tom Kearney.
Tom was almost killed by a bus in Oxford Street in 2009 and subsequently spent years examining London's contracted bus system.
His work helped drive greater public scrutiny of operator-level safety information and confidential reporting through CIRAS.
I first encountered Tom through the RMT Bus Workers Conference environment years ago, and his work had an enormous influence on my own thinking.
What struck me was his persistence in asking questions which the traditional system did not seem comfortable asking:
Who actually knows how many people are being injured?
Which operators are involved?
Where is the information published?
Can drivers report concerns without fear?
What happens after a serious collision?
Who learns from it?
And where does responsibility sit when a public authority specifies and manages the wider system?
Those questions stayed with me.
From London transparency to a national question
In 2019 I became involved in a national Freedom of Information exercise asking Local Transport Authorities whether they collected and published bus-safety information equivalent to that available in London.
What we found was not a clear national system.
It was fragmentation.
Different authorities collected different things.
Some had information.
Others did not.
Definitions differed.
Publication differed.
Responsibility was often unclear.
That led me increasingly to the conclusion that Britain needed a national bus-safety data standard rather than leaving every authority or operator to build its own picture.
Because if we cannot consistently answer basic questions about where passengers, pedestrians, cyclists, drivers and other workers are being injured, how can we confidently say whether safety interventions are working?
The campaign moved into trade-union policy
The same issues then began appearing repeatedly through RMT's specialist national Bus Workers Conference.
The National Bus Drivers' Bill of Rights brought together issues which are sometimes wrongly treated as separate industrial grievances:
safe schedules;
proper rest;
safe vehicles;
toilet and welfare facilities;
the right to raise safety concerns;
appropriate training;
freedom from unnecessary distraction while driving;
and dignity at work.
Behind all of those rights is one basic proposition:
driver working conditions and public safety are connected.
A driver does not stop being part of the safety system simply because a problem can also be labelled an employment issue.
Then came Parliament
In 2025 I submitted evidence to the House of Commons Public Bill Committee considering the Bus Services legislation.
The reforms advanced through our RMT Bus Workers Conference included proposals for:
confidential safety reporting;
routine publication of bus-safety performance;
stronger protection against driver fatigue;
appropriate safety competence for public bodies taking greater responsibility for bus services;
and an independent National Bus Crash Investigation Branch.
Those proposals were not invented in isolation.
They had grown out of years of evidence and campaigning.
Tom Kearney had been pressing many of the underlying issues in London.
Drivers including Lorraine Robertson had been giving evidence about timetable pressure, fatigue, toilet access and welfare.
Kevin Mustafa subsequently put powerful firsthand evidence before Parliament about fatigue, working conditions and fear of reporting.
Dave Holladay had argued years earlier that road collisions deserved the type of independent causal investigation routinely used in rail, aviation and maritime safety.
Different people.
Different backgrounds.
Different starting points.
But increasingly similar conclusions.
And now I discover the KSI Network
That is why discovering this Network matters.
Look again at what it says it wants to achieve.
Learning from serious and fatal incidents.
Sharing investigation outcomes.
Identifying recurring themes.
Improving safety data.
Developing national best practice.
Addressing fatigue.
Improving vehicle safety.
And ultimately exploring an RAIB-style model for road and bus investigation.
Those are not minor overlaps.
They are some of the central reforms campaigners have been demanding for years.
So I think it is reasonable to ask:
Is institutional policy finally beginning to catch up with what campaigners and frontline workers have been saying?
I don't ask that triumphantly.
And I certainly don't claim that the KSI Network exists because of any one campaigner, union or submission.
Policy development rarely works that neatly.
Many professionals inside TfL, DfT, local authorities, manufacturers and operators have also been doing serious safety work for years.
But when different groups independently arrive at similar conclusions, that tells us something.
It suggests the evidence is converging.
The independent investigation question is particularly important
Rail has the Rail Accident Investigation Branch.
Aviation has the Air Accidents Investigation Branch.
Maritime transport has the Marine Accident Investigation Branch.
Their central purpose is learning and prevention rather than establishing criminal or civil liability.
Bus and road transport do not currently have an equivalent independent statutory investigation system.
The KSI Network itself acknowledges this gap.
Rachel Birrell of TfL, a key figure in the Network, has publicly explained that rail, aviation and maritime transport all have independent accident-investigation branches which examine incidents and communicate lessons, while road transport and buses lack an equivalent.
The Network's wider ambition is described as an on-road alternative to the RAIB model.
That is enormously significant.
Because it means the argument for independent bus investigation is no longer simply coming from trade unions or campaigners outside the establishment.
People working within the national bus-safety architecture are identifying the same structural gap.
But the Network does not currently have those powers
This distinction is essential.
The Bus KSI Network is not currently a statutory accident investigation branch.
It does not appear to have powers equivalent to RAIB.
It does not independently compel evidence, seize records, formally reconstruct every serious collision or issue statutory recommendations to which organisations must respond.
Its present role is much more collaborative.
It facilitates learning.
It shares knowledge.
It connects professionals.
It identifies themes.
It spreads good practice.
And it seeks to influence policy and regulation.
Indeed, Rachel Birrell has described its role as facilitating and encouraging learning rather than setting regulatory targets.
That distinction should not be seen as criticism.
Every institution has to start somewhere.
The interesting question is:
what does it become next?
The safety-data issue could be transformational
There is another area where I believe the Network could become extremely important.
Bus safety data remain fragmented.
Police STATS19 information tells us important things, but it was never designed to provide the complete operational safety record of the bus industry.
A passenger who falls seriously inside a bus without a road collision may not fit neatly into the same dataset.
An incident inside a bus station may fall into a different category.
Operator information, police data, workplace reports and public-authority information can all tell different parts of the story.
What we need is not another competing dataset.
We need a common national safety language.
Every operator and authority should understand a collision, serious injury, passenger fall, assault, near miss and safety-critical defect in broadly the same way.
The KSI Network's interest in knowledge-sharing and common learning gives it a potentially important role in developing that architecture.
And if this is eventually coupled with routine public reporting, it could transform national scrutiny.
If we can measure punctuality, why can't we measure safety properly?
This question has become even more important with the rise of BODS and data-led bus regulation.
We are becoming increasingly sophisticated at measuring whether buses run on time.
We can analyse journey performance, cancellations, punctuality, live vehicle movement and network reliability.
DVSA and regulators are increasingly interested in using operational data to target enforcement.
I support good data and effective regulation.
But we should ask a very simple question.
Should Britain really become better at identifying a bus that is five minutes late than identifying and learning from patterns of serious injury across its bus network?
Performance data matter.
Safety data matter more.
The two should develop together.
Where are the frontline voices?
This brings me to the one question I think needs asking constructively.
I can see strong professional expertise around the KSI Network.
TfL.
Safety specialists.
Operators.
Manufacturers.
Public transport authorities.
Government.
Passenger and stakeholder organisations.
And its events have included union representatives and drivers. The Bus Safety Standard 2 event explicitly advertised participation from union representatives and drivers alongside operators, authorities and technical specialists.
That is encouraging.
But I have not yet found a published governance structure showing permanent, structured frontline bus-driver or recognised trade-union representation within the KSI Network itself.
That is different from saying drivers have been excluded.
I have seen no evidence that they are.
Indeed, membership appears open through the Bus Centre of Excellence, and the Network describes itself as open to bus professionals.
My question is slightly different.
Are frontline workers structurally embedded in the safety conversation?
Because attending a conference is not the same as helping shape the agenda.
Drivers hold safety information that no dashboard contains
Professional bus drivers see the system at street level every day.
They know the junction where near misses keep happening.
They know which timetable is routinely impossible.
They know where recovery disappears.
They know where buses repeatedly lose time.
They know where passengers regularly struggle to board.
They know which toilet is permanently locked.
They know which cab becomes unbearable in summer.
They know where antisocial behaviour repeatedly occurs.
They know which vehicle faults keep returning.
They know what happens when control-room instructions meet real traffic conditions.
And sometimes they know about a problem long before it becomes a KSI statistic.
That knowledge has enormous preventive value.
A national safety network should capture it before somebody is killed or seriously injured.
Trade unions have a role too
This is not about unions demanding control of the safety system.
It is about recognising what organised workforce representation can contribute.
A trade-union safety representative may see patterns across dozens or hundreds of workers which an individual employee does not.
They may hear about repeated fatigue.
A recurring vehicle issue.
A timetable problem.
A dangerous stop.
A welfare failure.
An instruction that is technically compliant but unsafe in practice.
They can also give workers confidence to speak honestly where there may otherwise be fear about employment consequences.
That is exactly why confidential reporting matters.
And it is why workforce representation should sit alongside engineering, regulatory, management and passenger expertise.
Safety works best when everybody brings a different piece of the picture
The best safety systems are not built exclusively by one profession.
Engineers understand engineering.
Human-factors specialists understand behaviour.
Manufacturers understand vehicle systems.
Operators understand operational management.
Authorities understand networks and contracts.
Regulators understand compliance.
Passengers understand their experience.
And drivers understand what actually happens when all of those systems meet at 7.30 on a wet Monday morning with traffic standing still, a full bus, an unrealistic running time and a service controller trying to maintain the headway.
None of those perspectives is sufficient alone.
Together they become powerful.
I don't want to attack the KSI Network — I want to engage with it
That is important.
Finding this Network has not made me think:
“Why haven't they done everything already?”
It has made me think:
“This could be an opportunity.”
Here is a DfT-funded national network openly discussing many of the things campaigners have demanded for years.
That should be welcomed.
It should also be tested.
Can it develop common safety data?
Can it improve national learning?
Can it connect information currently trapped inside individual operators?
Can it give drivers safe routes to contribute?
Can it make serious-incident lessons public?
Can it influence franchising contracts?
Can it push national safety standards beyond London?
And can its RAIB-style ambition eventually become something real?
Those are questions worth engaging with constructively.
Perhaps campaigners and institutions are finally meeting in the middle
For years, people such as Tom Kearney have pushed from outside the system.
Drivers such as Lorraine Robertson and Kevin Mustafa have spoken publicly about what working conditions look like from inside the cab.
Dave Holladay has argued for system-level risk analysis and independent investigation.
Trade unions have advanced resolutions.
Branches have submitted policy.
Campaigners have written to mayors and ministers.
Evidence has gone to Parliament.
FOI requests have exposed gaps.
Drivers have spoken up.
Sometimes progress has felt painfully slow.
But perhaps the emergence of a national network talking about data, fatigue, serious-incident learning and independent investigation shows something important.
Maybe the debate has moved.
The challenge now is implementation
Words matter.
Networks matter.
Conferences matter.
Sharing good practice matters.
But ultimately safety improvement has to reach the road.
It has to reach the cab.
It has to reach the timetable.
It has to reach the depot.
It has to reach the contract.
It has to reach the investigation.
It has to reach the data.
And it has to reach the worker who sees something dangerous and wonders whether anyone will listen.
That is the test.
What I would like to see next
I would like the Bus KSI Network to continue developing as a genuinely national safety-learning forum.
I would like to see common safety-data definitions.
I would like meaningful public reporting.
I would like systematic sharing of lessons from serious incidents.
I would like protected frontline reporting.
I would like recognised workforce representation embedded structurally rather than appearing only at individual events.
And I would like serious consideration given to turning the Network's RAIB-style ambition into an independent statutory investigation and learning function.
Not tomorrow.
Not without consultation.
And not by destroying what already works.
But as a serious national objective.
Franchising makes this even more urgent
The timing is important.
Across Britain, public authorities are taking much greater control of bus networks.
They increasingly influence routes, timetables, contracts, depots, fleets, performance measures and operational data.
That creates an extraordinary opportunity to build safety into the new system from the beginning.
A franchise contract can require safety reporting.
It can specify data standards.
It can demand fatigue-management arrangements.
It can require welfare facilities.
It can build confidential reporting into contracts.
It can require lessons from incidents to be shared across the network.
It can create structured workforce consultation.
Public control should not simply change who decides the fare.
It should improve how the system learns.
Is somebody finally listening?
I don't know yet.
I think it would be premature to claim that years of campaigning have suddenly been accepted.
And I certainly would not claim ownership of ideas that many people have developed independently.
But I do know this.
When bus drivers, trade unions, campaigners, Parliamentary witnesses, safety specialists, TfL professionals and a DfT-funded national network increasingly start talking about the same things —
fatigue;
safety data;
confidential reporting;
system learning;
vehicle design;
human factors;
public accountability;
and independent investigation —
then something important is happening.
The debate is converging.
The next job is turning convergence into action.
And perhaps the people who have spent years asking difficult questions should now be invited fully into the room where the answers are being developed.
That includes the people behind the wheel.
I write this in a personal capacity as a serving bus driver and trade-union representative. The views expressed are my own. This article is intended to encourage constructive discussion about national bus-safety governance and does not suggest that any individual organisation has acted improperly or that the Bus KSI Network excludes frontline workers. Its published activities have included drivers and union representatives; my question is whether frontline representation should become a more permanent and structured part of national bus-safety governance.
Comments
Post a Comment